A 11723: Provides that a communication or attorney work product otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or which otherwise shall not be obtainable by another party shall not lose its privileged or unobtainable character solely as a result of it being produced by, transmitted to, processed by, stored on, or otherwise facilitated through an artificial intelligence technology; requires authorization from the client to utilize artificial intelligence.
<p> This bill amends the Civil Practice Law and Rules to establish specific protections for attorney-client privilege and work product when artificial intelligence is used. It clarifies that communications or work product remain privileged even if they are generated, transmitted, processed, or stored by artificial intelligence technology, provided the communication was made in confidence for legal advice or strategy. Before using such technology, attorneys must provide clients with a notarized form authorizing its use; this form becomes effective when the client first engages with the attorney, regardless of when it is signed. The form must explain specific risks associated with artificial intelligence, including the potential for hallucinated or inaccurate content, unthorough reviews, and poor legal strategy. The bill ensures that clients are not responsible for errors made by artifici…
- What is the current status of A 11723?
- As of September 27, 2026, A 11723 is recorded as "Introduced": it has been introduced and is waiting for its first committee hearing or floor vote. The last recorded action, on September 16, 2026, was "referred to judiciary".
- Did A 11723 pass?
- Not yet. A 11723 has been introduced and has not passed either house.
- Who wrote A 11723, and where is it now?
- A 11723 was authored by Asm. Clyde Vanel. Its committee of record is Assembly Judiciary.
| Sep. 16, 2026 | referred to judiciary |
STATE OF NEW YORK ________________________________________________________________________ 11723 IN ASSEMBLY September 16, 2026 ___________ Introduced by COMMITTEE ON RULES -- (at request of M. of A. Vanel) -- read once and referred to the Committee on Judiciary AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to the use of artificial intelligence and attorney-client privilege and work product The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem- bly, do enact as follows: 1 Section 1. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new 2 section 4552 to read as follows: 3 § 4552. Attorney-client privilege and work product; artificial intel- 4 ligence. (a) For purposes of sections forty-five hundred three, forty- 5 five hundred forty-eight of this article, and subdivisions (c) and (d) 6 of section thirty-one hundred one of this chapter and any provisions of 7 law or common law which may relate thereto, a communication or attorney 8 work product otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or 9 which otherwise shall not be obtainable by another party shall not lose 10 its privileged or unobtainable character solely as a result of it being 11 produced by, transmitted to, processed by, stored on, or otherwise 12 facilitated through an artificial intelligence technology, as defined in 13 subdivision one of section seventeen hundred of the general business 14 law, including one operated by a third-party or on a private server, 15 provided that such communication or work product was made in confidence 16 for the purpose of rendering legal advice or strategy, or preparing, 17 editing, validating, or otherwise assisting in the preparation of legal 18 materials. 19 (b) Prior to utilizing artificial intelligence pursuant to subdivision 20 (a) of this section an attorney shall provide each client a form to be 21 signed and notarized authorizing such attorney to use such technology 22 for such purposes. 23 (c) The form described in subdivision (a) of this section shall be 24 effective on the date the client first engages with the attorney, 25 regardless of the date such form is signed or notarized. 26 (d) Such form shall explain the risks of using artificial intelli- 27 gence, which shall include the risk of: EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets [] is old law to be omitted. LBD16077-01-6A. 11723 2 1 1. Hallucinated content or case law; 2 2. Inaccurate content or case law; 3 3. Unthorough review of content or case law; and 4 4. Poor, inadequate or ill-advised legal strategy or arguments. 5 (e) No client of an attorney shall be responsible for errors with 6 respect to the use of artificial intelligence by an attorney, except 7 where the attorney is the client representing themselves pro se. 8 (f) No client shall be barred from asserting legal malpractice, inef- 9 fective assistance of counsel, any disciplinary complaint, or any other 10 related matter by authorizing the use of artificial intelligence under 11 this section. 12 (g) The form required by this section shall not permit an attorney to 13 use artificial intelligence technology to engage in such authorized 14 purposes under this section without human review. Where such form 15 contains such a provision, the form shall be deemed void ab initio, and 16 all information produced by, transmitted to, processed by, stored on, or 17 otherwise facilitated through such artificial intelligence technology 18 with respect to the particular client shall lose its privileged charac- 19 ter and shall be obtainable. 20 (h) Where a litigant is a pro se litigant, no form shall be required, 21 and the protections provided by this section shall presumptively apply 22 to such litigant. 23 § 2. This act shall take effect immediately.